What is Devolution?

From William Gladstone to Tony Blair and Andy Burnham, devolution has long been debated within British politics. Supporters argue that transferring power away from Westminster allows decisions to be made closer to the communities they affect.
Critics, however, question whether it risks creating regional inequalities and weakening the unity of the United Kingdom.
But what exactly is devolution, how does it work, and why has it become increasingly important in British politics?
What Is Devolution and How Does It Work?
Devolution refers to the transfer of political powers and responsibilities from central government to institutions operating at a national or regional level.
In the United Kingdom, devolution takes different forms. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own elected legislatures and governments, while parts of England have elected mayors and combined authorities responsible for particular regional policies.
The Scottish Parliament, Welsh Parliament (Senedd) and Northern Ireland Assembly can make decisions in areas such as health, education and transport, although their precise powers differ. Other responsibilities, including defence and foreign affairs, remain largely reserved to Westminster.
England's regional devolution operates differently. Combined authorities and elected mayors can exercise powers over areas such as transport, housing, economic development and skills, but they do not possess the same legislative authority as the devolved national parliaments.
Importantly, devolution does not mean independence. The UK Parliament remains sovereign, although established constitutional conventions generally discourage it from legislating on devolved matters without the relevant institution's consent.
Origins and Background in the UK
The debate surrounding devolution stretches back well over a century.
In 1886, Prime Minister William Gladstone introduced the First Irish Home Rule Bill, which proposed granting Ireland greater control over its domestic affairs.
Although the proposal failed, it helped establish a lasting debate about how political authority should be distributed within the United Kingdom.
A form of legislative devolution was eventually established in Northern Ireland in 1921, following the Government of Ireland Act 1920. However, its parliament was suspended in 1972 and abolished in 1973 amid the Troubles.
Modern devolution developed significantly under Tony Blair's Labour government.
In 1997, referendums in Scotland and Wales produced majorities in favour of establishing devolved institutions.
The Scotland Act 1998 and Government of Wales Act 1998 provided the legal foundations for the Scottish Parliament and National Assembly for Wales, which began exercising their powers in 1999.
Northern Ireland followed a different path. The 1998 Good Friday Agreement established a framework for power-sharing government, with devolved powers transferred to the Northern Ireland Assembly in December 1999.
Since then, the powers of these institutions have evolved, while devolution has increasingly expanded within England through elected mayors and combined authorities.
What Are the Benefits of Devolution?
One of the strongest arguments for devolution is that it allows policies to be tailored to the needs of individual regions.
A policy that works effectively in Greater Manchester may not necessarily be suitable for rural Cornwall or central London. By transferring decision-making powers to regional authorities, governments can respond more directly to local economic, geographical and social circumstances.
Devolution can also improve political accountability. When decisions are made closer to the communities they affect, voters may find it easier to identify which politicians are responsible for particular services and policies.
Another potential advantage is that regional leaders often possess a greater understanding of local challenges. This can help them prioritise investment in transport, employment, housing and infrastructure according to regional needs rather than relying entirely on decisions made in Westminster.
Devolution also provides opportunities for policy experimentation. Different regions can adopt alternative approaches to public services, allowing successful initiatives to influence policies elsewhere.
However, these benefits depend on whether devolved institutions possess sufficient funding, administrative capacity and genuine decision-making authority.
What Are the Drawbacks of Devolution?
Despite its potential advantages, devolution also presents challenges.
One concern is that transferring powers to regional authorities can create differences in the quality and availability of public services. This is sometimes described as a postcode lottery, where access to services varies depending on where someone lives.
Devolution may also increase political tensions between central and regional governments, particularly when different political parties control them. Disagreements over funding, taxation and policy responsibilities can complicate decision-making.
Regional political parties can also gain influence over national politics. Following the 2017 general election, for example, Theresa May's Conservative government reached a confidence-and-supply agreement with Northern Ireland's Democratic Unionist Party (DUP).
Although this arrangement was not itself a direct consequence of devolution, it demonstrated how parties representing particular parts of the UK can influence Westminster politics.
Another concern is that wealthier regions may be better positioned to benefit from devolved powers, particularly where local authorities have different economic resources and administrative capabilities.
Without appropriate funding and coordination, devolution could therefore reinforce existing regional inequalities rather than reduce them.
Why Does Devolution Matter Today?
Devolution has returned to the centre of British political debate, particularly following Andy Burnham's transition from Mayor of Greater Manchester to Prime Minister in July 2026.
Burnham served as Greater Manchester Mayor from 2017 until his return to Parliament in June 2026. During his mayoralty, he became closely associated with efforts to expand regional decision-making, particularly in public transport.
One prominent example was the introduction of the Bee Network, which brought Greater Manchester's local bus services under public control through a franchising system.
The programme was completed in January 2025, allowing local authorities greater influence over routes, fares and service standards.
This demonstrated how devolved powers could be used to pursue regional policy priorities, although the wider economic effects of devolution remain subject to debate.
Following his appointment as Prime Minister on 20 July 2026, Burnham placed further emphasis on transferring authority away from Westminster and Whitehall.
On 23 July, the government launched No. 10 North in Manchester, presenting it as a centre for coordinating national economic policy and strengthening cooperation between central government and regional leaders.
The October 2026 Budget further reinforced this direction.
The government announced that it was in the final stages of agreeing ten new devolution arrangements across England, including proposed mayoral authorities in Lancashire, Surrey, Hertfordshire and other areas.
According to the Treasury, these agreements would mean that more than 90% of England's population would be covered by a devolution agreement, with the government aiming for full coverage by the end of 2028.
The Budget also outlined plans to give regional authorities greater financial flexibility, including changes to business rates retention and future income tax assignment for mayors.
However, many of these measures remain proposals or agreements awaiting implementation. Their long-term effects on economic growth, regional inequality and public services have yet to be established.
The central question is whether expanding devolved powers will produce meaningful improvements for local communities or simply redistribute responsibilities without sufficient resources.
Conclusion
Devolution remains one of the most significant constitutional debates in British politics.
Supporters see it as an opportunity to bring political decisions closer to the public, strengthen regional accountability and create policies better suited to local circumstances.
Critics argue that it risks increasing regional inequalities, complicating political accountability and creating tensions between different levels of government.
The renewed emphasis on devolution under Andy Burnham's government suggests that the distribution of political power across the United Kingdom will remain an important issue in the years ahead.
Ultimately, the success of devolution will depend not simply on how much power is transferred away from Westminster, but on whether regional institutions have the resources, authority and accountability needed to use that power effectively.
References
Greater Manchester Combined Authority (n.d.) Bus Franchising. Available at: https://www.greatermanchester-ca.gov.uk/what-we-do/transport/bus-franchising
HM Treasury (2026) Budget 2026 Fact Sheet: Delivering for Every Region. 28 October. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/budget-2026-fact-sheet-delivering-for-every-region
HM Treasury (2026) Budget 2026. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/budget-2026-document/budget-2026-html
House of Commons Library (2024) Introduction to Devolution in the United Kingdom. 21 May. Available at: https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/CBP-8599/
House of Commons Library (2018) 20 Years of Devolved Statutes in Scotland and Northern Ireland. 19 November. Available at: https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-11719/
Prime Minister's Office (2026) No10 North Open for Business as the Government's New Situation Room for Making Britain Better. 23 July. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/no10-north-open-for-business-as-the-governments-new-situation-room-for-making-britain-better
UK Government (2026) The Rt Hon Andy Burnham MP. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/people/andy-burnham
UK Parliament (n.d.) Devolved Parliaments and Assemblies. Available at: https://www.parliament.uk/about/how/role/relations-with-other-institutions/devolved/




Comments