What Is Fascism, and When Can the Term Be Applied?

Fascism remains one of the most controversial and frequently debated concepts in modern politics. Originally associated with Benito Mussolini's Italy and Adolf Hitler's Germany, the term is now regularly used in discussions about authoritarianism, nationalism and the weakening of democratic institutions.
Its contemporary use, particularly in debates surrounding political developments in the United States and Israel, has raised an important question: what actually constitutes fascism, and when is it appropriate to apply the term to a political leader, movement or regime?
Although fascism is often used as a general description of oppressive or authoritarian politics, political historians and theorists argue that it possesses distinctive ideological characteristics. Understanding these characteristics is essential to distinguishing fascism from other forms of authoritarianism.
What Is Fascism?
Fascism is generally understood as a far-right, authoritarian and ultranationalist political ideology that rejects liberal democracy, promotes national unity under strong leadership and places the perceived interests of the nation above individual rights and political pluralism.
One influential interpretation comes from political historian Roger Griffin, who identifies fascism through the concept of palingenetic ultranationalism. This refers to the belief that a nation has entered a period of decline and must undergo a radical political and cultural rebirth to restore its former greatness (Griffin, 1991).
Fascism therefore goes beyond simply supporting a powerful government. It seeks to transform society around an idealised national identity, often identifying political opponents, minorities or external groups as obstacles to national renewal.
However, scholars disagree over which characteristics are essential to fascism. Some emphasise its ideology, while others focus on political violence, mass mobilisation and the destruction of democratic institutions.
The Origins of Fascism: Mussolini's Italy
Modern fascism emerged in Italy following the First World War, during a period of political instability, economic hardship and widespread nationalist dissatisfaction.
Although Italy fought alongside the victorious Allied powers, nationalists argued that the post-war settlement had failed to deliver all the territorial gains they expected. This perceived betrayal became known as the mutilated victory and contributed to growing resentment towards the liberal political establishment.
Italy also experienced unemployment, inflation, industrial strikes and fears of socialist revolution. These conditions created opportunities for political movements promising national unity, stability and decisive leadership.
Mussolini's rise to power
Benito Mussolini had initially been active in the socialist movement and served as editor of the newspaper Avanti!. However, he broke with the Italian Socialist Party in 1914 over his support for Italy's participation in the First World War.
In 1919, Mussolini established the Fasci Italiani di Combattimento in Milan, bringing together nationalist activists, war veterans and other groups dissatisfied with the existing political order.
The movement increasingly adopted violent anti-socialist positions. Its paramilitary supporters, known as the Blackshirts, attacked trade unions, socialist organisations and political opponents.
In October 1922, the Fascists organised the March on Rome. King Victor Emmanuel III declined to authorise military resistance and appointed Mussolini prime minister.
Mussolini did not immediately establish a complete dictatorship. Through electoral manipulation, political intimidation and the gradual dismantling of democratic institutions, his government consolidated authoritarian power during the following years.
The Italian experience demonstrates how fascist movements can exploit political instability and existing institutions to gain power before restricting political competition.
How Does Fascism Work? The Ten Pillars
In How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them (2018), philosopher Jason Stanley identifies ten recurring features of fascist politics.
Rather than treating fascism exclusively as a historical form of government, Stanley examines political techniques that can create division, undermine democratic norms and legitimise authoritarian power.
These ten features can be understood through three broader themes.
National identity and division
The mythic past: Fascist politics frequently invokes an idealised national past, presenting the present as a period of decline from which the nation must recover.
Hierarchy: Social and political inequalities are portrayed as natural or necessary, often placing one national, racial, religious or cultural group above others.
Victimhood: Groups with established social or political influence may be encouraged to view themselves as victims of minorities, outsiders or political opponents.
Appeals to the heartland: Rural or traditional communities are presented as representing the authentic nation, while cosmopolitan cities and cultural diversity are depicted as threats to national identity.
Political communication and public understanding
Propaganda: Political messaging is used to construct narratives that justify exclusion, strengthen loyalty and discredit opponents.
Anti-intellectualism: Academic institutions, journalists, experts and independent sources of knowledge are portrayed as untrustworthy or hostile to the nation.
Unreality: Conspiracy theories and misinformation undermine shared factual understanding, making democratic debate increasingly difficult.
Social control and political authority
Law and order: Political leaders emphasise threats from crime or disorder to justify stronger coercive powers and restrictions on civil liberties.
Sexual anxiety: Changing gender roles, women's rights and LGBTQ+ identities may be portrayed as threats to traditional society.
Attacks on public goods and unions: Institutions that promote collective organisation, education and solidarity can be weakened, reducing their ability to challenge concentrated political or economic power.
Stanley's framework illustrates how these political techniques may reinforce one another.
An idealised national past can encourage a sense of collective victimhood, while propaganda identifies supposed enemies responsible for national decline.
However, the presence of one or more of these features does not automatically establish that a government or political movement is fascist.
Stanley's framework identifies patterns of political behaviour rather than providing a universally accepted classification system.
When Can the Term Fascism Be Applied?
Applying the term fascism requires more than identifying authoritarian rhetoric or controversial government policies.
A useful distinction can be made between fascist political rhetoric, fascist movements and fascist regimes.
Fascist rhetoric may involve narratives of national rebirth, exclusionary nationalism or the portrayal of political opponents as enemies of the nation.
Such rhetoric can appear within democratic systems without necessarily defining the entire political movement.
A fascist movement involves a more organised ideological project. It may seek radical national transformation, reject democratic pluralism and legitimise political violence or coercion against opponents.
A fascist regime emerges when a movement acquires state power and establishes institutions reflecting its ideological objectives, often through the systematic suppression of opposition, concentration of authority and destruction of democratic competition.
Historian Robert Paxton emphasises the importance of examining what fascist movements actually do, rather than relying exclusively on their stated beliefs.
His approach considers how fascism develops through political mobilisation, alliances with established elites and the exercise of power (Paxton, 2004).
This distinction matters because authoritarianism and fascism are not interchangeable concepts.
An authoritarian government may restrict political freedoms and concentrate power without embracing fascism's revolutionary ultranationalism. Similarly, nationalism, conservatism or support for strict immigration policies do not individually make a political movement fascist.
A credible classification therefore requires evidence of a broader ideological and organisational pattern.
Historical and Contemporary Applications
Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany
Mussolini's Italy remains the foundational historical example of fascism. Its political system combined ultranationalism, authoritarian leadership, organised political violence and the suppression of democratic opposition.
Nazi Germany also displayed central characteristics associated with fascism, including dictatorship, mass mobilisation, expansionism and the destruction of political pluralism.
However, Nazism placed particularly strong emphasis on racial ideology, antisemitism and the pursuit of racial domination.
These characteristics culminated in the Holocaust and distinguish Nazi ideology from other
historical forms of fascism.
Both regimes demonstrate the consequences of movements that combined radical nationalism with coercive state power and the elimination of political opposition.
The United States: A Contemporary Debate
The term fascism has increasingly appeared in discussions of American politics, particularly in relation to Donald Trump and the wider Make America Great Again movement.
Some scholars and commentators draw comparisons between aspects of contemporary American political rhetoric and historical fascist techniques. These comparisons often focus on narratives of national decline, the portrayal of political opponents as threats, attacks on institutional legitimacy and demands for stronger executive authority.
Others argue that such comparisons risk overlooking important differences between contemporary American politics and the organised fascist movements of twentieth-century Europe.
For example, authoritarian populism, democratic backsliding and illiberal nationalism are alternative concepts used to analyse developments within democratic political systems.
The central question is therefore not whether a politician uses language resembling historical fascism, but whether their ideology, political organisation and conduct collectively support that classification.
Israel: Nationalism, Democracy and Political Classification
Debates about fascism have also emerged in relation to elements of Israeli politics, particularly concerning ultranationalism, minority rights, the treatment of Palestinians and the concentration of political power.
Critics of particular Israeli political movements have drawn attention to exclusionary nationalist rhetoric and proposals that could weaken democratic safeguards or restrict the rights of minority populations.
However, classifying an entire country as fascist risks overlooking differences between political parties, institutions and citizens. Israel's political system contains competing ideological movements, and the policies of a particular government should not automatically be attributed to the population as a whole.
Scholars may instead examine specific parties, politicians or political programmes, asking whether their stated objectives and actions reflect fascist ideology or are more accurately described through concepts such as ethnonationalism, authoritarianism or illiberalism.
The same evidential standards should apply when assessing any political movement, regardless of its national or ideological context.
Debates and Criticisms: Is Fascism an Overused Term?
Despite its historical significance, scholars continue to disagree about how broadly fascism should be defined.
Roger Griffin places particular emphasis on the ideological promise of national rebirth, while Robert Paxton examines the political behaviour and development of fascist movements.
Jason Stanley adopts a broader approach by identifying recurring political techniques that can undermine democratic institutions.
These differences create a central debate: should fascism be understood primarily as a distinct historical ideology, or can its political methods be identified across different contemporary contexts?
Critics of broad definitions argue that using fascism to describe every authoritarian or nationalist movement can weaken the term's analytical usefulness. It may obscure important distinctions between political systems and reduce complex political disagreements to ideological labels.
Conversely, scholars who emphasise fascist political practices argue that waiting until a fully established dictatorship emerges may overlook earlier warning signs of democratic erosion.
The challenge is therefore to recognise meaningful historical parallels without assuming that every similarity establishes ideological equivalence.
Why Does Fascism Matter Today?
Understanding fascism remains important because contemporary democracies continue to confront debates over nationalism, political identity, executive power and the protection of civil liberties.
Digital platforms have also transformed how political narratives circulate. Social media can amplify propaganda, conspiracy theories and attacks on independent institutions, raising questions about the relationship between political communication and democratic accountability.
At the same time, economic insecurity, cultural change and political polarisation can create conditions in which promises of national restoration become politically appealing.
These developments do not necessarily indicate the emergence of fascism. However, studying historical fascist movements provides a framework for examining how democratic institutions can become vulnerable to political exclusion, organised intimidation and the concentration of power.
Conclusion
Fascism is more than a general description of authoritarian government. It is a political ideology historically associated with radical ultranationalism, national rebirth, political violence and the rejection of democratic pluralism.
Its origins in Mussolini's Italy and its development in Nazi Germany demonstrate how political movements can exploit instability, construct narratives of national decline and consolidate power through the suppression of opposition.
Contemporary debates in the United States, Israel and elsewhere illustrate why the concept remains politically significant, but also why it must be applied carefully.
Identifying fascist rhetoric or political techniques does not necessarily mean that an entire movement or state is fascist. A convincing analysis requires attention to ideology, organisation, political behaviour and historical context.
Ultimately, the purpose of studying fascism is not simply to attach labels to political opponents, but to understand the conditions under which democratic institutions, individual rights and political pluralism can be undermined.
The important question is not only where fascism can be identified, but how political societies can recognise and respond to threats to democratic accountability before they become entrenched.
References
Griffin, R. (1991) The Nature of Fascism. London: Pinter.
Paxton, R.O. (2004) The Anatomy of Fascism. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
Payne, S.G. (1995) A History of Fascism, 1914–1945. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Stanley, J. (2018) How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them. New York: Random House.
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (n.d.) Fascism. https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/fascism-1


Comments